Showing posts with label Messier 1. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Messier 1. Show all posts

Sunday, March 22, 2026

A Deeper Look at M1: Discovering the Crab Pulsar in My Own Data

 And back we go to Super Bowl Sunday at the BMO ...

The Crab Nebula is one of the most studied objects in the night sky—but during the processing of this image, I realized I had captured something I didn’t expect at all: the Crab Pulsar itself.

On Sunday February 8, 2026, while I and another member were imaging the Horsehead and Flame (click here for that post) with the Tele Vue NP101is, our observatory director was imaging M1, The Crab Nebula on the Celestron 14" Edge HD. He was imaging with UV/IR Cut filter. This is a broadband filter, it is sometimes referred to as a luminance filter. I processed that data into an RGB or broadband image. This standalone RGB image is the second image in this post, because I was able (with help) to combine the RGB data with some narrowband data we collected in 2024.

On February 3, 2024 we captured data on M1 with the same telescope, a different brand camera with the same sensor type, and a dual narrowband filer that only captured the light from Hydrogen-alpha (Ha) and Doubly Ionized Oxygen (Oiii). Click here to view that post. After processing this dual narrowband data, I separated this image into separate Ha and Oiii images. The Ha and Oiii data was then combined with the RGB data from 2/8/2026 to produce this RGBHaOiii image.

Image 1: RGB + Ha+ Oiii Composite

A detailed astrophotograph of the Crab Nebula (Messier 1), a supernova remnant in Taurus. The nebula forms a tangled, web‑like structure of glowing filaments. Hydrogen‑alpha emission appears in bright pink and red strands, while OIII emission shows as blue‑green wisps woven throughout the cloud. The center glows more intensely, hinting at the energetic pulsar hidden within. Surrounding the nebula is a dense star field set against a dark background, giving the scene depth and contrast.
RGB plus HA and Oiii image of M1. A combination of data from 2026 and 2024.

Image 2: Standalone Broadband RGB

The RGB (broadband) image of M1 from 2/8/2026 at the BMO

Going down a Rabbit Hole 

I was reading an article on Universe Today on the Pulsar in the Crab Nebula on the Universe Today website (click here to go to the article). In the article there was a visible light image and the Crab Pulsar was visible. I had no idea the Crab Pulsar could would be detectable in an image. Could it be in the image of M1? 

Identifying the Crab Pulsar in my Image

I fired up PixInsight and visually compared my image to the image in the article. I was able to match up the stars in my image with the stars in the image in the article. There is a script in the Seti Astro grouping of scripts in PixInsight that identifies objects in your image. The script is called "What's in my image". It uses the astrometric solution of the image to identify the objects contained within it. I was able to create a search area around the star that matched the Crab Pulsar in the image in the article. The script, it confirms this is the Crab pulsar (see screenshot below). 

This is very exciting! I never imagined it was possible to capture the Crab Pulsar with amateur equipment! The Crab Nebula and the Crab Pulsar have been important objects to astronomy and astrophysics. I remember first learning about them as a child from Carl Sagan's Cosmos TV series and the companion book. To have not only captured the nebula (expected) but to have have also captured the Crab Pulsar is very exciting to me. 

Image 3: Screenshot from "What's in my image" script. 

A screenshot from PixInsight of the What's in My Image script result showing the Crab Pulsar. 

Image 4: Inset indicating location of Crab Pulsar in the image

This cropped and annotated inset indicates the location of the Crab Pulsar in the image.

Observatory

Both sets of images were captured at the Buffalo Astronomical Association's (BAA) Beaver Meadow Observatory (BMO). The BMO is located about 45 minutes southeast of Buffalo, NY in rural farm country. Our club's observatory is on the property of the Buffalo Audubon Society, near their Trillium Nature Center. We hold monthly Public Nights at the observatory on the first Saturday of the month, April through October. Note: July's Public night has been moved to July 18th as the 1st Saturday in July is Independence Day. 

Both the RGB and narrowband images of M1 were captured with our Celestron 14" Edge HD shown in the photo and video below. 

Image 5: Picture of the telescope used to capture the images of M1

Our club's Celestron 14" Edge HD Telescope on the Astro Physics AP1200 mount.

Image 6: A short video of the telescope slewing

What is it?

M1 is a supernova remnant. Humans observed the Supernova when it occurred in 1054. It was recorded by Chinese astronomers, and it appears that the event is also depicted in Petroglyphs in Arizona and New Mexico. The Chinese astronomers referred to it as a "Guest Star". it was visible during the day for 23 days and was visible at night for 653 days. The supernova also left behind a stellar remnant known as a Pulsar. The Crab Pulsar rotates 30.2 times per second. The nebula is expanding at a rate of 1,800 km/sec.

Image 7: An annotated version of the image of M1


An annotated version of the image of M1.

How big is it?

This object has an angular distance of 6 x 4 arcminutes (1 degree is 60 arcminutes) on the night sky. The object is 13 x 11 light-years (ly) across. 

How far is it?

It is located about 6,300 light-years (ly) from Earth in the Constellation Taurus.

How to find it?

This object is relatively easy to find. It's very close to the bright star Zeta Tauri in the constellation Taurus. Refer to the finder chart below. This is a great visual target. It can be seen in binoculars and small telescopes. Dark skies help as it is it can get lost in light polluted skies. Larger aperture helps significantly. Although visible in smaller instruments, I believe it is far more interesting to observe in large aperture scopes. Nebula filters can aid in viewing this object.

Image 8: A finder chart for M1

Finder chart for M1.

Processing:

In short, the workflow involved many of the usual processing elements gradient removal, deconvolution, noise reduction, star separation, narrowband blending, and final HDR balancing with blending in the narrowband data to the RGB data. Detailed steps follow for those interested.

I was able to process both the RGB and the narrowband images into pleasing images separately. I struggled with getting a good result when trying to combine the Ha and Oiii from the narrowband image with the RGB image. I reached out to my friends at the YouTube channel AstroWorld TV for help. They invited me on and we worked on processing the image on the episode 503 of the show. I did make a few minor edits after the show as the image appeared too bright when viewed on devices other than the laptop I processed it on. Thank you to the team at AstroWorld TV for their help! Especially Super Dave!

Image 9: A screenshot of YouTube episode 503 of AstroWorld TV

The RGBHaOiii image of M1 was processed with help from my friends at AstroWorld TV.

Narrowband Image:

Gradient removed with GraXpert. The narrowband image was aligned to the RGB image with Star Alignment. The registered image was cropped using Dynamic Crop and the instance of the process was saved to the desktop so it could be used to duplicate the crop the RGB image. BlurXTerminator was used for deconvolution and the stars were removed with StarXTerminator. We did not save the narrowband stars. Noise was reduced with NoiseXTerminator. The image was made non-linear with Generalized Hyperbolic Stretch. Non-linear processing: The image was separated into the R, G, & B channels using Channel Extraction. The R image was used as the Ha image and the B & G images were averaged together to become the Oiii image. We tried performing Continuum Subtraction on the Ha & Oiii images, but did not get good results.

RGB Image:

Gradient was removed with GraXpert. The image was cropped to duplicate the narrowband images with the saved instance of Dynamic Crop. BlurXTerminator was performed in correct only mode. color calibration was performed with SPCC. BlurXterminator was used for deconvolution. The stars were removed (and saved) with StarXTerminator. Starless linear processing: The image was made non-linear with Generalized Hyperbolic Stretch.

Starless non-linear processing: The image blend script was used twice to blend in the Ha and Oiii to the RGB base image. Image blend was used for sharpening by using the high pass filter. CT was used to enhance color and color saturation.

Stars: Stars were stretched with Seti Astro's Star Stretch script. CT was used to enhance color and saturation.

Final: The stars were screened back into the starless image with PixelMath. After the show, I viewed the image on several devices and decided it was too bright. I used the CreateHDRImage script to tone down the core. 

RGB Image Details:

Capture Date: 02/08/2026
Location: Beaver Meadow Observatory (North Java, NY)
Telescope: Celestron 14" Edge HD w/0.7x Reducer
Camera: OGMA AP26CC
Filter: OGMA 2" UV/IR Cut
Mount: Astro Physics AP-1200
Exposure: 19 exposures at 300 sec / Gain 100 / Offset 50 / -25°C each for a total exposure of 1 hour and 35 minutes.
Software: NINA, PHD2, and PixInsight

      Narrowband Image Details:

      Capture Date: 02/03/2024
      Location: Beaver Meadow Observatory (North Java, NY)
      Telescope: Celestron 14" Edge HD w/0.7x Reducer
      Camera: ZWO ASI2600MC Pro
      Filter: Optolong l-eXtreme 
      Mount: Astro Physics AP-1200
      Exposure: 13 exposures at 600 sec / Gain 100 / Offset 50 / -10°C each for a total exposure of 2 hours and 10 minutes.
      Software: NINA, PHD2, and PixInsight

      Conclusion

      What began as a routine multi‑wavelength image turned into a reminder of how much is still hidden in our data. With careful processing and a bit of curiosity, even well‑known objects like M1 can still surprise us.

      Clear Skies!
      Ernie

      Thursday, February 8, 2024

      A Tale of Two Supernovae ... Part 1

       Saturday Night at the Observatory

      It has been several months since we have had a clear night. It was clear Saturday night 2/3/2024 into Sunday morning 2/4/2024. Our Astronomy club’s imaging group assembled at our Dark Sky Observatory. We call ourselves the Tuesday Night Imagers, but Tuesday night can be any night of the week.  We put my camera (ZWO ASI2600MC Pro) on the club’s Celestron 14” Edge HD Telescope which is on an Astro Physics AP-1200 mount. An Optolong L-eXtreme Dual-Narrowband filter was used to target specific wavelengths of light.

      The imaging team (for the club's equipment) was our Observatory Director (Dan), a member named Mike, and me. Our target was Messier 1 (M1) a.k.a. The Crab Nebula. M1 is a supernova remnant located in the constellation Taurus. We lost some time at the beginning of the night getting things running. The Observatory had not been used (due to poor weather) since mid-December. Programs and drivers needed to be updated and we needed to fine tune the Acquisition software for this new Telescope/Camera combination. We started to acquire images at 8:40 PM and imaged until 11:30 PM when we lost M1 to the Muck near the horizon and the trees. We closed the roof and took our flat frames. Mike removed his camera from the Tele Vue NP-10is that rides on the mount with the 14" Edge HD. We replaced it with an eyepiece to keep things close to balance so Dan and I could go after one more target. We'll cover that in part 2.

      We did encounter an issue with aberrations (spikes) on our stars. We were unable to resolve the issue Saturday night. Dan and Mike returned to the observatory Monday evening, and I joined them via Zoom. After some troubleshooting, we believe the issue is caused by the Celestron Dew Heater Ring. Even with the Star spike issue, we managed to collect 13 usable subs at 600 sec each for a total exposure of 130 minutes. Here is the resulting image:

      M1, The Crab Nebula from 2/3/2024, HOO version. BAA Tuesday Night Imagers.

      Processing:

      I did all pre and post processing in PixInsight. Pre-processing: Blink & WBPP. Linear Post-processing: GraXpert, BlurXTerminator (correct only), Spectrophotometric Color Calibration, BlurXTerminator, NoiseXTerminator, and Histogram Transformation. Non-Linear Post-processing: StarXTerminator. Starless: Narrowband Normalization (two methods as described below), Curves (Multiple iterations to increase brightness, contrast, and color saturation), SCNR, Local Histogram Equalization, Unsharp Mask, and Multiscale Median Transform. Stars: Curves (to increase color saturation) and SCNR. PixelMath was used to screen the stars back in. 

      I tried to different methods in the Narrowband Normalization process. Method 2 which produces an HOO result and Method 1, which produces a result that simulates the Hubble or SHO palette. The image above is the HOO version. I prefer this version. Here is the simulated SHO version:

      M1, The Crab Nebula, simulated SHO Version. BAA Tuesday Night Imagers.

      What is it?

      M1 is a supernova remnant. Humans observed the Supernova when it occurred in 1054. It was recorded by Chinese astronomers, and it appears that the event is also depicted in Petroglyphs in Arizona and New Mexico. The Chinese astronomers referred to it as a "Guest Star". it was visible during the day for 23 days and was visible at night for 653 days. The supernova also left behind a stellar remnant known as a Pulsar. The Crab Pulsar rotates 30.2 times per second. The nebula is expanding at a rate of 1,800 km/sec.

      Annotated image of M1, The Crab Nebula. 

      How big is it?

      This object has an angular distance of 6 x 4 arcminutes (1 degree is 60 arcminutes) on the night sky. The object is 13 x 11 light-years (ly) across. 

      How far is it?

      It is located about 6,300 light-years (ly) from Earth in the Constellation Taurus.

      How to find it?

      This object is relatively easy to find. It's very close to the bright star Zeta Tauri in the constellation Taurus. Refer to the finder chart below. This is a great visual target. It can be seen in binoculars and small telescopes. Dark skies help as it is it can get lost in light polluted skies. Larger aperture helps significantly. Although visible in smaller instruments, I believe it is far more interesting to observe in large aperture scopes. Nebula filters can aid in viewing this object.

          Finder Chart for M1.

          Image Details:

          Capture Date: 02/03/2024
          Location: Beaver Meadow Observatory (North Java, NY)
          Telescope: Celestron 14" Edge HD w/0.7x Reducer
          Camera: ZWO ASI2600MC Pro
          Filter: Optolong l-eXtreme 
          Mount: Astro Physics AP-1200
          Exposure: 13 exposures at 600 sec / Gain 100 / Offset 50 / -10°C each for a total exposure of 130 minutes (2.2 hours)
          Software: NINA, PHD2, and PixInsight


          Clear Skies!
          Ernie

          Follow

          Beyond the Stars: Revealing the Double Cluster’s Faint Hα Glow

          From a Shared View to a New Imaging Project The story behind this image began with a shared view through a telescope at our club’s September...